As Good as It Gets movie poster
Poster © Sony Pictures Releasing. Shown at reduced size for review and commentary.
GenreComedy, Drama & Romance
RatedPG-13
Runtime2 hr 19 mins
ReleasedDecember 25, 1997
StreamingSee Where to Watch
DirectorJames L. Brooks
StarringJack Nicholson, Helen Hunt, Greg Kinnear

As Good as It Gets (1997)

movie.guru URL: https://movie.guru/as-good-as-it-gets-movie-review
As Good as It Gets's Details
GenreComedy, Drama & Romance
RatedPG-13
Released12/06/1997 (Regency Village Theatre); 12/25/1997 (United States)
StreamingSee Where to Watch on this page.
Running Time2 hr 19 mins
Budget$50M (reported)
Box OfficeUpdated daily from Box Office Mojo. See the numbers below.
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
As Good as It Gets's Interests
GeneralPlastic cutlery, sidewalk cracks, double-checked locks, the same table every morning, Verdell.
MusicHans Zimmer, who got an Oscar nomination for the score.
MoviesTerms of Endearment (1983). Same director, same Nicholson, more tears.
TelevisionMonk. Another brilliant guy who will not touch the doorknob.
HeroesVerdell. A tiny dog that softens the grumpiest man in New York.
As Good as It Gets's Crew
DirectorJames L. Brooks
WritersMark Andrus, James L. Brooks, Mark Andrus (story)
ProducersJames L. Brooks, Bridget Johnson, Kristi Zea
CinematographyJohn Bailey
MusicHans Zimmer
Edited ByRichard Marks
ProductionTriStar Pictures, Gracie Films
Distributed BySony Pictures Releasing
As Good as It Gets's Trailer
Official Trailer • Sony Pictures Entertainment
How As Good as It Gets Performed
movie guru's TLDR

Melvin Udall insults pretty much everyone he meets in As Good as It Gets, and the movie treats a lot of that cruelty like a quirky trait instead of a real problem. His digs at his gay neighbor Simon land as punchlines, and some have aged terribly. The romance has a math problem too: Carol is a smart, worn-out single mom, and the movie needs you to believe a couple of nice gestures cancel out years of nasty behavior. And yet. Jack Nicholson is so precise, so funny and so obviously scared under the bluster that you can’t look away. Helen Hunt is the real engine, sharp, fed up and refusing to be anybody’s prize. Greg Kinnear gives Simon a quiet dignity the script barely earns. The sneakiest scene stealer is Verdell, a tiny dog who picks up Melvin’s habit of hopping over sidewalk cracks. A 7.0 because the performances are wonderful and the guy at the center gets forgiven way too easily. $466 says you step over a sidewalk crack this week on purpose and can’t explain why.

What works: Jack Nicholson, Helen Hunt and Greg Kinnear are all terrific, and the dialogue crackles.

What doesn’t: Melvin’s cruelty is played for laughs too often, and the romance asks Carol to forgive far more than it should.

Who it’s for: People who like grumpy-guy-softens comedies and can watch one with a critical eye.

Spoilers

On the road trip to Baltimore with Simon, Melvin tells Carol she makes him want to be a better man, then wrecks the evening anyway. Back home, he shows up at her door before dawn, they walk to a corner bakery, and Melvin steps on a sidewalk crack without even noticing.

Guru’s Take
7.0/10
Above Average
As Good as It Gets's Blurbs
About me:

Melvin Udall (Jack Nicholson) writes bestselling romance novels and is rude to absolutely everyone. He also lives with obsessive-compulsive disorder, which means every lock gets checked over and over, no stepping on sidewalk cracks, and breakfast at the same table every day with his own plastic cutlery. Carol Connelly (Helen Hunt) is the only waitress who will put up with him. When his neighbor, painter Simon Bishop (Greg Kinnear), ends up in the hospital after a robbery, Simon's agent Frank Sachs (Cuba Gooding Jr.) leans on Melvin to look after Simon's dog, Verdell. James L. Brooks directs. One hundred thirty-eight minutes, one tiny dog with huge influence.

Who I'd like to meet:

Anyone who brings their own silverware. Verdell says hi.

As Good as It Gets's Cast (in credits order)
Jack NicholsonMelvin Udall
Helen HuntCarol Connelly
Greg KinnearSimon Bishop
Cuba Gooding Jr.Frank Sachs
Skeet UlrichVincent Lopiano
Shirley KnightBeverly Connelly
Yeardley SmithJackie Simpson
Lupe OntiverosNora Manning
JillVerdell
Bibi Osterwaldneighbor woman
Brian Doyle-Murrayhandyman
Missi PyleCafe 24 waitress
Leslie StefansonCafe 24 waitress
Shane BlackBrian
Randall BatinkoffCarol's date
Lisa Edelsteinwoman at table
Peter Jacobsonman at table
Jesse JamesSpencer "Spence" Connelly
Jamie Kennedystreet hustler
Justin Herwickstreet hustler
Maya Rudolphpolicewoman
Lawrence KasdanDr. Green
Wood HarrisCafe 24 busboy
Julie Benzreceptionist
Full cast and crew on IMDb.
As Good as It Gets's Edit History
Every change to this page, newest first. Movie data updates are logged like any other edit.
  • (cur | prev) 14:30, 17 October 2026 DataBot +480 Numbers refreshed: Worldwide box office $314.2M; Domestic box office $148.5M; Opening weekend $12.6M; Profit / loss (est.) +$82.1M; Rotten Tomatoes 86%; CinemaScore A−; box office chart updated; Rotten Tomatoes critics 86% (84 reviews); Metacritic 67 / 100; CinemaScore A−; IMDb users 7.7 / 10 (340,995 votes); movie.guru score 7.6.
  • (cur | prev) 12:00, 17 October 2026 DataBot +2,000 Profile created from Wikipedia and Box Office Mojo: cast, crew, release dates, budget, official trailer.