The Testament of Ann Lee (2025)

At 136 minutes, The Testament of Ann Lee asks for real patience, and the long middle can feel like a New England winter. Mona Fastvold tells the story of the woman who founded the Shakers as a full musical, built on real Shaker hymns, with worship that shouts, sings and dances. Amanda Seyfried gives the performance of her career as Ann, a girl from the Manchester cotton mills who becomes Mother Ann to her followers. She’s fierce and tender, and she never plays Ann as a fool or a saint. The film takes her faith on its own terms. Lewis Pullman is quietly moving as her brother William, her most loyal believer. A storm at sea, with Ann keeping everyone’s spirits up, is a highlight, and a number showing the Shaker style taking shape in furniture and buildings is gorgeous. It made $4.2 million worldwide on a reported $11M. An 8.1 because it takes belief seriously and swings big. $82.33 says you run your hand along a plain wooden chair at a furniture store this month and suddenly respect it.

What works: Amanda Seyfried is extraordinary as Ann, and the hymn-driven musical numbers make the Shakers’ worship feel thrilling and alive.

What doesn’t: At 136 minutes the pace sags, especially in the long middle stretch, and the film’s tone can feel elusive and hard to read.

Who it’s for: Viewers who love bold historical films, sacred music and big, fearless lead performances.