movie.guru feed • Watch List

If You Loved Fargo, Watch These 8 Next. Number One Will Start a Fight.

Posted October 23, 2026 • by movie guru

Friday, October 23, 2026

Fargo is a dumb plan, a smart cop and jokes in a crime scene. These eight carry that DNA. Some carry it better than you'd admit.

Number one isn't a Coen movie, and it's the truest heir anyway.

  1. 8Reservoir Dogs poster
    Reservoir Dogs (1992)9.3
    Same botched-crime energy, smaller budget, way more talking.
    A robbery goes sideways and Steve Buscemi is in trouble again. Shot for a reported $1.2 to 3M, it scores 9.3. Less snow, more arguing about tipping.
  2. 7The Departed poster
    The Departed (2006)9.0
    Fargo's nervous laughs, swapped for Boston accents and bigger egos.
    Cops, crooks and everyone lying to everyone. 9.0 on movie.guru, $292M worldwide. My take is 8.6 because Nicholson plays it like the camera owes him money.
  3. 6Road to Perdition poster
    The most underrated winter crime movie of the 2000s.
    A family man stuck in mob business he can't control, cold and grey everywhere. 7.7 on movie.guru, my take 8.2. The slow pace will test you.
  4. 5The Order poster
    The Order (2024)7.7
    The cold-weather cop movie nobody bothered to see.
    A worn-out FBI agent working a small, frozen Pacific Northwest town. 93% on Rotten Tomatoes, just $2.0M domestic. Heavy subject, so zero Fargo giggles here.
  5. 4Hell or High Water poster
    The closest thing to a Fargo sequel, minus the snow.
    Small-town lawman, desperate money scheme, dry jokes in tense rooms. 97% on Rotten Tomatoes off a reported $12M budget. Jeff Bridges mumbles like he's saving words for winter.
  6. 3Eastern Promises poster
    A decent person wanders into crime and can't back out.
    That's the Fargo engine, moved to London. 8.7 on movie.guru, only $17.3M domestic. One bathhouse fight is legit too intense for some viewers.
  7. 2No Country for Old Men poster
    Same directors, colder heart, fewer jokes. Still essential.
    The Coens again: a tired sheriff, found money, a very bad man. 9.3 on movie.guru, my take 9.4. Kelly Macdonald gets way too little screen time.
  8. 1Nightcrawler poster
    Nightcrawler (2014)7.8
    The real Fargo heir, and the Coens finished second.
    A polite guy with a business plan and zero conscience, deadpan the whole way. 7.8 on movie.guru, B-minus CinemaScore, my take 8.7. Audiences flinched. That's the point.
Change my mind. Rank these from most to least Fargo. Wrong answers only.

$226.13 says you finish Nightcrawler and call me wrong in the comments before the credits end.

Share it: X | Facebook | Copy link

Current mood: ready to fight about it