Every movie here scored 9.7 or higher on movie.guru, where 5.5 is the median movie. Nobody here is bad. The order is where friendships end.
Number 1 beat Casablanca with one room and zero car chases. Stretch first.
- 8
The crowd's 9.7 is louder than the movie.
It beat 100% of audience scores and pulled $30.2 million worldwide. The Guru's Take is a 6.9, so the fan love is doing serious heavy lifting here.
- 7
Kubrick's angriest movie, and the generals earn every frame.
96% on Rotten Tomatoes, 90 on Metacritic. Kirk Douglas versus his own brass. The trenches are great, the courtroom is greater, and that imbalance is why it sits at #8's doorstep.
- 6
Hollywood roasting itself before roasting was a genre.
Reported $1.8 million budget, 98% on Rotten Tomatoes, 94 on Metacritic. Gloria Swanson goes huge on purpose. William Holden narrates like a man filing a complaint. Still meaner than modern satire.
- 5
Barely a drama. Still out-dramas most dramas.
Charlie Chaplin versus a factory, 96 on Metacritic, audience score beating 100% of movies. It's tagged Comedy first, so drama purists get exactly one valid complaint today.
- 4
Every team-up movie since is a remix of this.
100% on Rotten Tomatoes, 98 on Metacritic, 407,225 IMDb votes. Toshiro Mifune is a human firework. It asks for a full evening, and the first hour tests people.
- 3
The greatest movie ever made about minding your neighbors' business.
Reported $1 million budget, $37.6 million domestic, a perfect 100 on Metacritic. James Stewart barely leaves his chair and it's still tenser than most chase movies.
- 2
Most quotable script ever, and it absolutely knows it.
Perfect 100 on Metacritic, 663,156 IMDb votes, reported $1 million budget. Bogart and Bergman carry it, Claude Rains steals it. Second only because a jury room got there first.
- 1
One sweaty jury room beats Casablanca. Fight me.
IMDb 9.0 on over a million votes, 100% on Rotten Tomatoes, 97 on Metacritic. Henry Fonda argues with an eyebrow. Recorded worldwide gross in our data: $15,647. Legit nuts.
Change my mind. Rank these from most to least drama. Modern Times fans, prepare your defense.
$612.47 says the first comment is someone demanding to know where The Godfather went.
Share it: X | Facebook | Copy link
Current mood: ready to fight about it