It's Wednesday. Plan your Sunday now. These romances run long, the scores say they earn it, and every one has a flaw anyway.
#1 beats the highest-scored classic in the pile. Fight me in the comments.
- 8
Fincher's prettiest movie, and also his sleepiest.
Brad Pitt ages backward while Cate Blanchett does the heavy lifting. A 72% on Rotten Tomatoes says critics checked their watches. Audiences still beat 85% of movies. Bring a blanket.
- 7
Russell Crowe sings like he's being audited. Still worth it.
Anne Hathaway carries the whole thing. Critics gave it a 63 on Metacritic, audiences gave it an A CinemaScore and $442.8 million worldwide. The crowd won this argument.
- 6
The strangest love story here, and the most rewarding.
Emma Stone goes full feral and Mark Ruffalo's cad is a riot. An 88 on Metacritic, but audiences beat only 79% of movies. Strictly grown-up viewing.
- 5
Half a story, full price, zero regrets.
Jon M. Chu split the musical in two and it still feels generous. $475 million domestic and an A CinemaScore. Jonathan Bailey steals every scene he dances through.
- 4
Best Hunger Games. The love triangle is still its weakest part.
Jennifer Lawrence sells every glare. 90% on Rotten Tomatoes and $869.9 million worldwide, while Liam Hemsworth mostly stands around District 12 looking concerned.
- 3
Jenny deserved a better script than this movie gave her.
Robin Wright plays a character the film keeps punishing. Still, an A+ CinemaScore and an 8.8 IMDb rating from 2.5 million votes. The crowd forgives everything.
- 2
The most romantic movie here isn't really about one couple.
It's a love letter to a small-town movie theater. A 9.4 movie.guru score, audiences beat 99% of movies, all on $13.5 million worldwide. Pack tissues.
- 1
Better than Gone with the Wind. Yes, I said it.
Gone with the Wind scores 9.5 here, Titanic 8.4. The Guru's Take flips it, 8.9 to 6.8. Billy Zane is a cartoon, and $2.26 billion worldwide shrugs.
Change my mind. Rank these from best to most skippable, or come defend Gone with the Wind.
$1,471 says you start Titanic at noon and the snacks are gone before the iceberg shows up.
Share it: X | Facebook | Copy link
Current mood: ready to fight about it