movie.guru feed • Watch List

If You Loved The Godfather, Watch These 8 Next. Number One Will Start a Family Feud.

Posted October 31, 2026 • by movie guru

Saturday, October 31, 2026

The Godfather is family, power and men making quiet decisions at tables. These eight carry that DNA, and every one scores Elite on movie.guru.

Number one isn't a mob movie at all. Make your case in the comments.

  1. 8The Sting poster
    The Sting (1973)9.5
    The Godfather's grinning little brother from 1973.
    Same era, same suits, same men making deals in back rooms. Here the swindle is the plot, and it pulled $156M domestic on a reported $5.5M budget.
  2. 7Taxi Driver poster
    Taxi Driver (1976)9.5
    Young De Niro, 1970s New York, zero hope. Perfect pairing.
    Same decade, same rot, same question about what a city does to a man. Scorsese made it on a reported $1.9M and it still lands a 9.5.
  3. 6Memories of Murder poster
    A slow burn crime drama that out-dreads most thrillers.
    Like The Godfather, it lets silence do the heavy lifting. Song Kang-ho is great and the Guru's Take is 9.3. Only $15,357 domestic, which is a scandal.
  4. 5City of God poster
    City of God (2002)9.4
    A crime empire built from nothing, told across years.
    The Godfather's rise of a family, moved to a Rio neighborhood. Its audience score beats 100% of movies on movie.guru, and it lands a 9.4.
  5. 4Dog Day Afternoon poster
    The truest Godfather follow-up isn't called Godfather.
    Al Pacino and John Cazale reunite as two very bad bank robbers, with Pacino sweating through every scene. Lumet turned a reported $3.8M into $50M domestic.
  6. 312 Angry Men poster
    12 Angry Men (1957)9.8
    Godfather's best scenes are men at a table. So is this.
    One room, twelve jurors, a life on the line, and power shifting with every vote. Highest movie.guru score on this list at 9.8, and IMDb voters give it a 9.0.
  7. 2Goodfellas poster
    Goodfellas (1990)9.7
    The obvious pick, and it's obvious because it's correct.
    Same mob, same loyalty, none of the romance. De Niro and Pesci, Scorsese at full speed, and a 9.7 movie.guru score with 1.4 million IMDb votes.
  8. 1Knives Out poster
    Knives Out (2019)9.4
    Yes, a whodunit. It's secretly a Godfather family movie.
    A rich patriarch, an empire, and a family circling it like sharks in sweaters. Same succession fight, more jokes. $312.9M worldwide on a reported $40M budget.
Change my mind. Wrong answers only: what's the real Godfather follow-up?

$271.47 says someone calls #1 a crime against cinema, then admits they've seen it three times.

Share it: X | Facebook | Copy link

Current mood: ready to fight about it