Simon Pegg has two giant franchises and an ice cream trilogy on his résumé. The scores are huge. The crowds, weirdly, were not.
Number one is a cult classic you swear isn't underrated. The box office disagrees.
- 8
Overstuffed and overpriced, but the crowd was right about it.
Audiences rated it above 83% of movies, critics only 63%. Reported budget of $300M to $400M, fewest IMDb votes here at 243,539. Bloated, sure. Still a 7.6.
- 7
Fans skipped the most fun Trek of the reboot run.
CinemaScore A minus, 86% on Rotten Tomatoes, then $343M worldwide on a $185M reported budget. Box office isn't profit, and that math is grim for a movie this lively.
- 6
Brad Bird made the most rewatchable Mission, full stop.
94% on Rotten Tomatoes, $694M worldwide, and a Guru's Take of 8.4 over its 7.9 movie.guru score. Critics beat 83% of movies. The crowd lagged at 73%.
- 5
The quiet middle child that out-plots its louder siblings.
Guru's Take 8.6, above its 8.2 movie.guru score. $710M worldwide on a $150M reported budget, and people still can't remember which one it is.
- 4
Part One gets treated like homework. It's a 9.1.
96% on Rotten Tomatoes, CinemaScore A, audiences above 93% of movies. Only 334,678 IMDb votes though, fewer than Rogue Nation's 451,375. Strange choice, internet.
- 3
Best action movie of its decade, and fewer people rate it.
98% on Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic 87, $824M worldwide. It still has 144,331 fewer IMDb votes than Ghost Protocol. The helicopter deserved more paperwork.
- 2
The ice cream trilogy entry everyone skips is the smartest one.
Metacritic 81, critics above 82% of movies. Audiences gave it 57%, a B+ CinemaScore and $46M worldwide. The Guru's Take of 7.6 says they blinked first.
- 1
Your favorite cult comedy is still underrated. Yes, Hot Fuzz.
A 9.0 movie.guru score, audiences above 94% of movies, Guru's Take 9.1. It made $23,637,265 domestic. Everyone quotes it. Almost nobody paid to see it.
Change my mind. Rank these from most to least underrated. Wrong answers get screenshotted.
$583.62 says you type 'Hot Fuzz is NOT underrated' in the comments, then rewatch it tonight anyway.
Share it: X | Facebook | Copy link
Current mood: ready to fight about it