Tom Hanks doesn't really make bad movies. He makes movies where everyone around him makes bad choices. Here's his bottom 8 by movie.guru score, receipts included.
Number 1 is a camera that never moves. Some of you will defend it.
- 8
Elvis lands here because Hanks played the villain.
Austin Butler did the hip work. Hanks did a mystery accent under a pound of prosthetics. Audiences still loved it: A− CinemaScore, $288.7M worldwide on a reported $85M budget.
- 7
A volleyball out-acted half of Hollywood that year.
Tied with Elvis at 7.5, which is wrong. Hanks talks to sports equipment for an hour and it made $429.6M worldwide. The B CinemaScore is an insult to Wilson.
- 6
He's the big-box bookstore guy and we're supposed to swoon.
Nora Ephron and Meg Ryan sell it anyway, and $250.8M worldwide says dial-up flirting worked. A 58 on Metacritic says critics noticed he's kind of a corporate shark.
- 5
Critics flew coach on this one. They were wrong.
61% on Rotten Tomatoes, but a 7.4 on IMDb from 544,065 votes. Hanks camping at an airport gate is way cozier than a Spielberg airport movie has any right to be.
- 4
Messy, overstuffed, and secretly the most underrated thing here.
Three directors, a reported budget up to $146.7M, and just $27.1M domestic. The C+ CinemaScore is fair. The Guru's Take is still 6.7, way above its 5.3.
- 3
Better than The Da Vinci Code. Low bar, cleared.
Robert Langdon speed-walks through Rome solving riddles while Ewan McGregor looks suspicious. Critics gave it 36%. It still pulled $485.9M worldwide because every dad bought a ticket.
- 2
Biggest hit on this list, and it's mostly a lecture.
$801.3M worldwide, 25% on Rotten Tomatoes. Ian McKellen is having a blast. Everyone else is explaining paintings to each other in very dark rooms.
- 1
Lowest score, but the most interesting failure on the list.
One camera, one living room, a lot of de-aging. Only $16M worldwide on a reported $45 to 50M budget. Guru's Take is 4.3, because at least nobody else tried this.
Change my mind. Rank these from most to least underrated. Wrong answers only.
$726.41 says the first comment is someone yelling that Cast Away doesn't belong on this list.
Share it: X | Facebook | Copy link
Current mood: ready to fight about it