movie.guru feed • Hot Take

8 Giant Action Movies That Made a Billion and Nobody Can Explain Why

Posted October 27, 2026 • by movie guru

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Every movie here made over a billion dollars worldwide. None of them scored above a 5.8. We're not mad. We're just asking questions.

Number one has the most loyal fans in the galaxy. Sorry in advance.

  1. 8Aquaman poster
    Aquaman (2018)5.8
    Aquaman is a fun mess, not a billion dollar movie.
    $1.15 billion worldwide on a 5.8 movie.guru score. Jason Momoa carries it like a beach towel. Everything else is a treasure hunt with a light show.
  2. 7Transformers: Dark of the Moon poster
    Dark of the Moon is a car commercial that got lost.
    Critics gave it 35% on Rotten Tomatoes. The planet still paid $1.12 billion worldwide. Michael Bay basically invoiced Earth for noise.
  3. 6Jurassic World Dominion poster
    Dominion cleared a billion purely on the word Jurassic.
    $1.002 billion worldwide, 29% on Rotten Tomatoes, a 4.1 movie.guru score. It squeaked past the billion line by about $2 million. Laura Dern deserved a better script.
  4. 5Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides poster
    On Stranger Tides is a Jack Sparrow screensaver.
    Reported budget of $410.6 million, $1.047 billion worldwide, 32% on Rotten Tomatoes. Ian McShane is the only one on that ship who seems awake.
  5. 4Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom poster
    Fallen Kingdom is the most expensive shrug in dinosaur history.
    $1.31 billion worldwide, the biggest gross on this list, with a 4.3 movie.guru score. It beat only 30% of movies with critics. The dinosaurs did all the work.
  6. 3Transformers: Age of Extinction poster
    Age of Extinction is the worst movie here, and it's not close.
    18% on Rotten Tomatoes, a 32 Metacritic, a 3.1 movie.guru score. Still $1.105 billion worldwide. Mark Wahlberg replaced Shia LaBeouf and somehow it got louder.
  7. 2Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker poster
    Fans graded it a C minus and still paid a billion.
    Opening crowds gave it a C minus CinemaScore. It pulled $1.077 billion worldwide anyway. That's not love. That's a nine movie habit nobody wanted to break.
  8. 1Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace poster
    The Phantom Menace is a 5.0, and the pod race can't save it.
    $1.047 billion worldwide, 54% on Rotten Tomatoes, a 5.0 movie.guru score. Liam Neeson and Ewan McGregor try so hard. The trade dispute plot defeats them both.
Change my mind. Rank these from most to least unexplainable. Wrong answers only.

$1,451 says someone in the comments defends the trade dispute plot with a completely straight face.

Share it: X | Facebook | Copy link

Current mood: ready to fight about it